The pitcher does have a unique characteristic going for it - that being the uncommon manner in which the slip decoration was applied. A splatter technique was used rather than brush strokes or a similar approach. I can only speak for myself when I say I have never seen another form of New England redware with such a splatter technique. The slip in this case is thickly applied. I have seen some splatter, but nothing that resembles this manner and especially nothing from before 1800. I have seen it used in Pennsylvania, New York and possibly North Carolina, but those finished products are completely different than how this product appears.
18th Century Redware Pitcher
Demonstrates a Very Unique Splattered Slip Decoration
I was told the pitcher had been consigned from a Boston-area residence, but its true provenience was not entirely known. Its size reminded me of similar forms sometimes associated with John Henry Benner in Abington, Massachusetts and the potters who worked further north and south along coastal Massachusetts.
Partial Redware Kiln Furniture Still Attached to Base
I have only read about an eighteenth century splash technique applied by potters - never before had I seen it in person. Lura Woodside Watkins discussed a similar technique in Early New England Potters and Their Wares - Christopher Leffingwell (1734-1810) worked in Norwich, Connecticut. Watkins wrote in detail of shards she saw on the site of his business that mostly appeared in a late eighteenth century context.
"It will be seen that this early Connecticut pottery turned out many of the same articles that the Massachusetts men were making. Many of the shards that we found were slip decorated on backgrounds of dark brown, brick red or tan. Both white and black slips were used...Leffingwell's workmen were drawn from New York rather than Northern New England, we would expect them to make the types of ware that prevailed around New York...Another Connecticut type found frequently in and about Norwich and New London is the cylindrical jar of deep red splashed with black. Similar jars are attributed to Norwalk and I have seen one of known New Jersey origin. I have never found these in Massachusetts potteries. The splash technique appears on the fragment of a bowl with rim rolled back in a delicate curve."
There were more than a dozen potters who worked in Norwich in the eighteenth century, but none appear to have owned any type of background from the Massachusetts industries. It is not entirely know if the Massachusetts type influence seen in Connecticut is merely a coincidence or whether it was drawn from Old World techniques. Most of the redware made in eighteenth and nineteenth century Connecticut found inspiration from the potters who worked in New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania. There really were not a lot of similarities to New England wares. Connecticut ultimately took on its own appearance when compared to the rest of New England. I personally do not believe the pitcher has any type of connection to the industry in Connecticut. I merely found it interesting to see a similar so-called splash technique referenced in New England during the eighteenth century.
My recent studies at the Narbonne House in Salem, Massachusetts have provided impressive results which tie a number of important colonial earthenware industries to the waterfront property. The Narbonne House was built in the latter years of the seventeenth century. The home has always remained under either a middle-class ownership or occupancy through the mid-twentieth century. The home has been the residence of many local artisans and skilled craftsman. I will not get into much-more detail since eighteenth century Salem will be a part of the book I am working on, but I will share a small part of what I have found. The property was well preserved and it kept a group of eighteenth and nineteenth century privies. As part of the ceramic collection were eighteenth and nineteenth century redware crocks, chamber pots and an assortment of flatware that can be tied to the industries in Charlestown, South Danvers and Newburyport, Massachusetts. Everything I have seen thus far can be tied to these three areas and there does not appear to have been any outside areas that imported into Salem beyond European imports.
Narbonne House - Salem, Ma
Dates Back to the 17th Century
Within the ceramic collection, there is a chamber pot with a very unique decoration that is decorated in exactly the same manner as the redware pitcher of discussion. The chamber pot was found in a 1770 context. It may date earlier. It is described as, "red-blown glaze interior and exterior with splattered slip decoration." It is seen to the far left in the photo below.
Photo Courtesy: National Parks Services Archaeology Department - Narbonne House - Salem, Ma
(Not to be Reused Without Permission from NPS and EarlyAmericanCeramics.com)
It is my belief that there is still much-more to be learned of the early potters in Essex County. It has been suggested that very-little slip decoration was ever attempted in this region beyond the Kettle family who helped found the industry in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth century. It is my belief that this pitcher is an example of a potter or maybe a business which is relatively unknown today. This pitcher may be one of the few examples of colonial Essex County redware with applied slip decoration to exist. I personally, do not know of any others. The pitcher could be a representative sample of the many earthenware businesses that flourished in the eighteenth century, but are mostly forgotten today. It is even more exciting to say it could possibly date back many years before the American Revolution happened. I do not have enough proof yet, but I think the pitcher could possibly be a very rare example of redware made in Beverly, Massachusetts. The color of the reddish-brown background is also a regular characteristic seen in eighteenth and nineteenth century Massachusetts in the communities north of Boston. Whoever the potter was must have seen enough success that there was a market in Salem they could export to. There is a chance the potter sold similar wares directly across the street from the Narbonne House at the docks on Salem's waterfront. This is at the least, the place where they may have unloaded their wares for a possible merchant.
Crudely Applied Handle
Pitcher was Likely made in Essex County, Mass - Ca. 1770 or Possibly Earlier
I have written extensively about the potters of early Essex County Massachusetts - you can search the website for a number of reports. Those reports include shards found on the shores of Danversport which demonstrate slip decoration similar to those seen from the Kettle Pottery (17th or early 18th century) as part of Lura Woodside Watkins collection at the Smithsonian in Washington, D.C. A similar decoration was seen on the flatware found at the Narbonne House. There will be much more on that subject in the the ongoing book that I am working on.
It's even more fascinating to grasp the concept that this splatter decoration does not appear to have been uncovered in anymore major archaeological sites with any type of relationships or similarities to Salem; such as those in Charlestown and Boston - and in Portsmouth, New Hampshire. It appears it may only be seen Salem. So - could this be a product of an unknown Salem, Massachusetts potter!? That would be extremely exciting! I am certainly not ruling that out. I would also like to say that this pitcher is proof slip decoration was used in Essex County in the years that led up to the American Revolution and probably afterwards.
The archaeology of the Narbonne House is absolutely amazing. The redware collection shows Salem was a hot spot for redware makers directly to the west, north and south of the maritime city in the eighteenth century. The industry to the west appears to become Salem's main supplier by the beginning of the nineteenth century. That is all I will tell about Salem for now!
Much More to Come...










