Massachusetts auctioneer, David Straight sold a nineteenth-century red earthenware milk pan earlier this week at an auction in Sturbridge, Massachusetts. These type of pans are often difficult to properly attribute to a specific potter's business today since the form has been produced for centuries, which dates back to the ancient Roman period. Although, this pan would likely be attributed to Maine today, as-a-result of its colorful glaze; however, I have an argument that explains why this object was likely made near Sturbridge at a central Massachusetts potter's business, circa 1860.
I own a matching (or very-similar) glazed red earthenware jar that is attributed to Abner S. White, a nineteenth-century red earthenware potter, who is known to have worked in Marlborough, New Hampshire, Keene, New Hampshire, West Sterling, Massachusetts and East Brookfield, Massachusetts. I would not normally develop an attribution on glaze, but there may be an exception here since this jar and pan are decorated with basically matching unusual glazes.
I believe this jar was likely made in West Sterling, circa mid-nineteenth-century by reason of another jar that I own in a very-similar form, which is marked with Wight's stamp, '
A.S. Wight.' To my knowledge, this stamp was only used in West Sterling, circa 1860-1865/66.
In an article written by Edwin H. Coolidge in 1932 for '
Old Time New England,' '
The Pottery Business in Sterling,' "The Wachusett Pottery was established in West Sterling, Massachusetts in 1820 based on surviving letterheads from the company." But, the earliest evidence that Coolidge discovered was in 1837, when the Troy, New Hampshire potter, Henry Tolman (1783-1851) purchased land for a red earthenware business in West Sterling.
According to Massachusetts author, Lura Woodside Watkins (
Early New England Potters and Their Wares), "Henry Tolman was assisted as-early-as 1837, and then succeeded by his son Henry Tolman, Jr. (1810-1892), who in 1849 was running the West Sterling business under the name, 'H. Tolman, Jr. & Co.' The father had evidently retired and died two years later.
The firm is also listed in the New England Directory of 1849 as ' Tolman & Wight.'
It is possible that Abner S. Wight, son of John Wight of Dublin, New Hampshire already had an interest in the West Sterling pottery, although, by all accounts, he did not purchase it until about 1860.
In 1856, the firm's name was 'Wight & Willard' (later A.S. Wight & Co., circa 1860-1865/66), Tolman had withdrawn from the partnership. Abner S. Wight and his associate carried on a thriving business until after the close of the American Civil War.
The pottery's affairs were then taken over by Marcus L. Snow, James Smith, and Marcellus Wight, who was Abner Wight's son, as 'Snow, Smith & Company.'
In 1869, it was in the hands of Snow and a new partner, Henry Coolidge, who ran the works successfully as 'Snow and Coolidge' until the death of the latter in 1881."
Note: I have shown a collection of four jars that I own, which I believe are all related to Abner S. Wight's production in West Sterling, Massachusetts. I attribute all of these jars to the circa 1860-1865/66 period, as to when Wight owned the business in West Sterling. The marked jar corresponds with the name of the business and the form is very-similar to the remaining three jars; although, I also suspect that the three remaining jars may date to an earlier (or briefly later) production period in West Sterling, as well.
I also want to mention that two of these jars are colorfully glazed - I could also easily see them attributed to Maine today. This is why it is risky to develop an attribution only based on the glaze.
Here is also a
link to the auction catalog from David Straight's January 31st sale in Sturbridge, Massachusetts.
Red Earthenware Pan
19th Century Red Earthenware Pan
Possibly Made by Abner S. Wight in West Sterling, Mass.
Circa 1860
Stands 3 1/2" Tall
Measures 17" in Diameter
Sold: $150
Photo Courtesy: D.L. Straight Auctioneers - Sturbridge, Mass.
View of the Base
Photo Courtesy: D.L. Straight Auctioneers - Sturbridge, Mass.
View of the Glaze
Photo Courtesy: D.L. Straight Auctioneers - Sturbridge, Mass.
Another View of the Glaze
Photo Courtesy: D.L. Straight Auctioneers - Sturbridge, Mass.
Matching (or Very-Similar) Glaze
19th Century Red Earthenware Jar
Attributed to Abner S. Wight - West Sterling, Mass.
Found in Central Mass.
Circa 1860
Stands 8 1/2" Tall
The Glaze Matches or is Very-Similar to the Glaze Found on the Pan
Another View of the Glaze/Jar
Collection of Jars
Collection of 4 Red Earthenware Jars Attributed to Abner S. Wight
(Left) 19th Century Red Earthenware Jar
Attributed to Abner S. Wight - West Sterling, Mass.
Circa 1860
Stands 8" Tall
(Right) 19th Century Red Earthenware Jar
Attributed to Abner S. Wight - West Sterling, Mass.
Circa 1860
Stands 8 1/2" Tall
(Left) 19th Century Red Earthenware Jar
Stamped with Abner S. Wight's Mark - West Sterling, Mass.
Stamp Used Circa 1860-1865/66
Stands 9 1/4" Tall
(Right) 19th Century Red Earthenware Jar
Attributed to Abner S. Wight - West Sterling, Mass.
Circa 1860
Stands 8 3/4" Tall
View of the Mark
View of the A.S. Wight Mark
Stamp Used Circa 1860-1865/66
Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come...