Wednesday, March 9, 2016

The Origin of Red Earthenware Pots Owned by Winterthur in Delaware and Old Sturbridge Village in Massachusetts

Old Sturbridge Village in Sturbridge, Massachusetts owns a large black-glazed red earthenware pot that appears eighteenth-century in origin. I do not know the exact measurements; however, I presume that this large pot must stand about twelve-inches-tall. My immediate reaction was that it may have been produced in Buckley, England in the eighteenth or nineteenth-century.

Sherds from black-glazed utilitarian wares attributed to Buckley have been recovered in numerous eighteenth-century archaeological contexts in America, such as Portsmouth, New Hampshire, Salem, Massachusetts, Charlestown, Massachusetts, Boston and New York City.

For example, various black-glazed sherds attributed to Buckley were recently uncovered by archaeologists at Faneuil Hall in Boston that predate 1742. Faneuil Hall was Boston's major import and export location before the American Revolution - the fact that sherds from red earthenware products made in Buckley were recovered at this location suggest that these type of products were imported from England in the eighteenth-century. It should not be surprising, either that eighteenth and nineteenth-century Buckley-made products are found in a variety of American contexts today. These objects are sometimes attributed to certain American potters.

According to Prifysgol Aberystwyth Univeristy in England; "The area around Buckley has been associated with the production of pottery from the medieval period up to the closure of the last pottery in 1946. The most productive time was from the late-seventeenth-century through the late-eighteenth-century although there was still an extensive market for Buckley slipware in the nineteenth-century. Characteristics of Buckley ware are all kinds of large (hand) thrown storage vessels for household and dairy use along with press moulded baking dishes with bold slip decoration. Towards the end of the nineteenth-century with the decline in the market for brown household pottery the potters diversified and produced more small decorative pieces."

Despite comparable characteristics, I am not, yet certain that the pot owned by Old Sturbridge Village is an English product. Although, the glaze-style and clay color does correspond with black-glazed wares made in Buckley in the eighteenth and nineteenth-centuries. 

Yesterday, when I was reviewing Winterthur's red earthenware collection kept in Wilmington, Delaware, when I realized that the museum owned a similar object. The only difference was the size of their pot, which also exhibited less tooling around the base. However, the lack of tooling around the base may have also been the result of the smaller pot, as well. Otherwise, the two pots are basically mirror images of each other in form and glaze.

According to Winterthur, "The pot was made in Nova Scotia, Canada during the 1850-1870 period." I have asked knowledgeable people in Canada, whether Winterthur's attribution is correct, and the feeling is that Winterthur's pot does not completely comply with what is perceived as traditional Nova Scotia-made red earthenware today. However, they also said that there are always exceptions to the rule. Nonetheless, the Nova Scotia's potter's industry was influenced by English-made red earthenware in the nineteenth-century.

Personally, I still feel there is a solid argument that can be made for a Buckley, England attribution for both of these objects. There is just something about the pot owned by Old Sturbridge Village that suggests (to me) that it was manufactured in the eighteenth-century.

Old Sturbridge Village Black-Glazed Pot

 18th or 19th Century Black-Glazed Red Earthenware Pot
Possibly Made in Buckley, England or Nova Scotia
Stands Approximately 12" Tall
Photo Courtesy: Old Sturbridge Village - Sturbridge, Mass.
View of the Handle
Photo Courtesy: Old Sturbridge Village - Sturbridge, Mass.

Winterthur Black-Glazed Pot

19th Century Black-Glazed Red Earthenware Pot
Purportedly Made in Nova Scotia
Circa 1850-1870
Stands 7 5/8" Tall
Photo Courtesy: Winterthur - Wilmington, DE

Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come...

Tuesday, March 8, 2016

A Wonderful 19th Century Slip-Decorated Red Earthenware Pitcher Owned by Winterthur in Wilmington, Delaware

I was going through Winterthur's collection of red earthenware kept in Wilmington, Delaware earlier today, and I was surprised to see a few objects that I plan to write about tonight and tomorrow. Notably, there was an example of Charles A. Lawrence Pottery (circa 1866-1906) made in Beverly, Massachusetts. The museum did not provide a specific attribution; however, the pitcher was properly attributed to Essex County, Massachusetts. These type of objects are commonly attributed elsewhere today to places such as Pennsylvania, Virginia and western New York.

The museum suggested that this pitcher was produced during the 1800-1830 period; however, it was actually produced later in the nineteenth-century. It's understandable why this period was suggested, too as-a-result of the slip-decoration. Instead, this object was actually made in the late-1860's or the 1870's. The slip decoration is an early-style; although, Charles A. Lawrence was arguably unique for New England after 1850 since he regularly decorated utilitarian red earthenware in multiple styles of slip-decoration.

The fact that this pitcher retains its original lid today is fascinating. This is only the second lid that is known to have survived today from the C.A. Lawrence Pottery. A friend helped me locate and acquire the only other known lidded pitcher a few years ago - that object currently resides in my private collection today. The fact that the only lid, which I have handled is very-thinnly-made may suggest why so few lids have survived - they were beautifully made, but they likely broke easily, too. A thicker-made lid may have only chipped when it hit another object, but my feeling is that these Beverly lids easily broke.

I have previously stated that any type of slip-decorated red earthenware from Beverly is rare today considering that these types of products were only made for about a decade before the company changed focus to produce high-end decorative wares in the 1870's, the 1880's and the 1890's. Utilitarian wares were still made; however, they were no longer the focus of the company.

 19th Century Slip-Decorated Red Earthenware Pitcher
Attributed to the Charles A. Lawrence Pottery - Beverly, Mass.
Retains Its Original Lid
Circa 1866-1906
Stands 6 1/2" Tall
Photo Courtesy: Winterthur - Wilmington, DE
View of the Base
Photo Courtesy: Winterthur - Wilmington, DE

Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come...

A Wonderful 19th Century Southern Stoneware Pitcher that is Scheduled to Sell in North Carolina Later this Month

A great piece of southern stoneware is scheduled to sell at Brunk Auctions in Asheville, North Carolina on Friday March 18, 2016. Reportedly, this object has been repaired; however, the repair does not affect my opinion of this piece since this is such a rare form to find today from an important nineteenth-century South Carolina potter's business.

The object is described as a "nineteenth-century alkaline glazed stoneware pitcher with a white loop slip-decoration over a brown ground. It is attributed to Collin Rhodes (1811-1881) in Edgefield, South Carolina, circa 1850. The handle has been repaired. The pitcher was consigned from a private New York collection."

Interestingly, this pitcher last sold at Brunk Auctions in 2009 for $8,800, which does not include the buyer's premium. With the eighteenth-percent buyer's premium, this pitcher ultimately sold for $10,384 in 2009.

The recent history that accompanies this object indicates that it was discovered at a (southern) flea market in 1977. Unfortunately, I am not currently aware whether the restoration happened before or after its discovery in 1977.

According to an online article, 'Rhodes to Our Roots,' written by Keever Rhodes, "Collin Rhodes was the owner of the Pottersville Stoneware Manufactory and the Phoenix Factory in Edgefield, South Carolina. Collin was a notable producer of ceramics and opened a plantation workshop where slip decoration and alkaline-glazed stoneware was produced for merchants throughout South Carolina.

Collin Rhodes sold his property in Edgefield, South Carolina in 1853, and moved to Bienville Parish, Louisiana, in 1854 with 43 slaves." 

This may be a question that has already been published with Edgefield's recent scholarship; however, I would still like to ask the question since I do not know the answer; Did Collin Rhodes continue to produce stoneware in Louisiana? Is there any evidence that could remotely suggest this happened? The only Louisiana stoneware that I know of today is the merchant jugs that are found all over America from the latter-years of the 1800's. These jugs are often stenciled with merchant information.

 19th Century Stoneware Pitcher Attributed to Collin Rhodes - Edgefield, SC
Reportedly Found at a Flea Market in 1977
The Handle Has Been Repaired
Circa 1850
Stands 11" Tall
Scheduled to Sell in North Carolina on Friday March 18, 2016
Photo Courtesy: Brunk Auctions - Asheville, NC
 View of the Slip Decoration
Photo Courtesy: Brunk Auctions - Asheville, NC
View of the Base
Photo Courtesy: Brunk Auctions - Asheville, NC

Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come...

Monday, March 7, 2016

A Rare Pair of 19th Century Red Earthenware Potter's Molds that Sold a Few Weeks Ago in Pennsylvania

On Saturday February 27, 2016, Whitman Auctioneers, Inc. in Manheim, Pennsylvania sold a collection of nineteenth and twentieth-century red earthenware that was predominantly made in Pennsylvania. For reference, I have included the pottery portion from the auction listing below.

There were two specific objects in this collection that I felt were museum quality. They were loaf dish molds, which were used by a potter to press mold red earthenware in the nineteenth-century.  Afterwards, the loaf dish was likely decorated with slip-decoration.

One of the loaf dishes was inscribed, "B.B. Mershon / February 26th, 1828." Unfortunately, my brief attempt to identify this potter has been unsuccessful, thus far; however, Christie's in New York City sold a slip-decorated red earthenware loaf dish in 1997 that was probably made from a similar mold - it was inscribed, "B.B. Mershon / February 25th, 1848." Ultimately, the loaf dish sold for $633.00, including the buyer's premium.

It would be incredible to own a loaf dish mold, and a red earthenware dish with the same inscription, as seen below.

The other loaf dish mold is not marked; however, I thought it was equally intriguing due to the rarity of finding any type of nineteenth-century red earthenware potter's tool today.

************* 

Outstanding Antiques Auction Including the 2nd Session of the Private Collection of the Late Greg Zieber (Master Potter of Robesonia), and other Local Collectors.

18TH & 19TH CENTURY PA REDWARE POTTERY (STAHL, MEDINGER, HENNE, AND OTHERS), 20TH CENTURY POTTERY BY NOLDE FOREST, BREININGER, WES MUCKEY & GREG ZIEBER AND OTHERS


Redware/Pottery:  Nolde Forest Redware Items (Vases, Easter Rabbit, Mug, Decorated Plate, Eggs, Miniature Face Jug, Face Mug, Decorated Pot, Soap Dish),  Breininger Items (Extremely Rare & Unusual Fish Bottle, Decorated Cake Stand, Twisted Rope Handled Pitcher, Die-Cut, Double Walled Lidded Jar, Pr. Salt & Pepper Shakers, Fabulous Miniature Grouping of Four (4) Pitchers, Slip Decorated Butter Pats, Soap Dishes, Eggs, Toddy Plates, Bowls, “Sample Plates”, Redware Barrel Keg, Decorated Ovoid Vase, Lidded Jar, Decorated Cup, Fat Lamps, Extremely Large Platter w/Squiggle Design, Bowl w/ Fish Decoration, Extremely Early Bulbous Form Jug Dated 1967, Goose Neck Teapot, Decorated Bowls, Full Bodied Lion – Many of These Pieces are Signed By Greg Zeiber and Wes Muckey), Stahl Pottery (Exceptionally Fine Redware Egg Cup- Signed & Dated Isaac Stahl ’48, Green Decorated Lidded Gooseneck Teapot – Signed & Dated Isaac Stahl 1935, Extremely Rare Pinch Bottle – Signed & Dated Isaac Stahl 1948, Small Green Decorated Flower Pot, Twisted Rope Handled Cup, Unsigned Twisted Rope Handled Small Jug, Glazed Handled Beer Mug)Miscellaneous Redware Items: Jacob Medinger Pie Plate w/Decorated Design, Extremely Rare J.S. Henne Berks County Storage Vessel and Jug, Sponge Decorated Jars, Cups, Mugs, Turks Head Molds, Inkwell, Colander, Double Handled Jar, Wooden Molding Bowls, Ovoid Handled Still Bank, Miniature Ovoid Bottle, Large Incised Double Handled Storage Vessel, Twig Pottery Bank, Flower Pot, Fine Large Handled Pot w/ Lid, Loaf Dish Mold – Signed B.B. Mershom 1828, Very Early Oversized Oval Dish Mold, Good Selection of Early PA Redware (Many Pieces From Berks County), Oversized Slip Decorated w/ Squiggle & Dot Decoration, Slip Decorated Tick-Tack Toe Plate, Slip Decorated Pie Plate, Octagonal Slip “Leaf and Floral Decorated” Plate, Large Slip Decorated Bowl, Highly Decorated Slipware Plate w/Yellow & Green Décor, Twentieth Century Redware Including Nolde Forest, Breininger, Jeff White, Pottery  

19th Century Loaf Dish Mold Used to Produce Red Earthenware
Inscribed 'B.B. Mershon / February 26th, 1828'
Photo Courtesy: Whitman Auctioneers, Inc. - Manheim, PA
19th Century Loaf Dish Mold Used to Produce Red Earthenware
Photo Courtesy: Whitman Auctioneers, Inc. - Manheim, PA

Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come

An Important 18th Century Red Earthenware Jar Acquired Yesterday in Portsmouth, New Hampshire

According to Massachusetts author, Lura Woodside Watkins important book, 'Early New England Potters and Their Wares,' "Brimfield, Massachusetts is said to have had its local potter as early as 1780. There is some question about the potter's name, but information obtained by Rev. Randolph Hill from Miss Anna Tarbell, who owned a pitcher made in Brimfield, seems to verify the fact that the maker was David Bugbee (1749-1822). If so, he was perhaps the son of Daniel Bugbee of Woodstock, Connecticut, a one-time resident of Brimfield, as there is no record of a David Bugbee being born in the town."

Also according to Watkins, "Thomas Bugbee, Jr. (1761-1843 - brother of David Bugbee) founded a well-known pottery in South Woodstock, Connecticut in 1793. Bugbee, who was then thirty-three years old, was apparently untrained in the potter's art, for he employed a 'foreign' artisan to oversee the various processes of preparing the clay and glazing wares. The word 'foreign' does not necessarily mean his master workman came from across the sea, but perhaps only from Massachusetts or a distant part of Connecticut; in those days of limited travel, all outside towns were foreign. So we would not expect Bugbee's output to differ in any respect from the wares made elsewhere in New England. It is said that he produced large quantities of pottery. In six firings during the summer, he burned some five thousand pieces. Of these, two thousand were milk pans. They were (reportedly) distributed by cart to stores in all the neighboring settlements of Windham County (Connecticut). The pottery continued until 1843, when its owner died."

I purchased the following important eighteenth-century red earthenware jar from Massachusetts antiques dealer, Samuel Herrup at an antique show in Portsmouth, New Hampshire this past week weekend. This acquisition did not come as a surprise, either since I was already aware of this jar's existence prior to yesterday's show.

This double-handled jar is believed to be a product of the Bugbee family made before 1800; however, whether it is a product made in Connecticut or Massachusetts is open to debate. Personally, I do not know of any archaeological evidence that could support either claim, but there is more information that may help with a proper identification.

An old tag, which accompany's this jar, reads, "Probably made in / Woodstock, CT by / Bugbee." Although, I have also been told that this jar was originally discovered in the Brimfield, Massachusetts-area.

Nevertheless, this is a very-rare object to find today - in fact, any type of eighteenth-century New England-made red earthenware is exceptionally rare today - yet, the size of this object, and its appearance make it extra special.

This jar  is also likely living proof of the potter's businesses that began to emerge away from coastal New England around the American Revolution. There are very-few survivors known from this transition period today.

I have visited numerous museum's storage facilities, such as Historic New England, Old Sturbridge Village and the Smithsonian; truthfully, I have, yet to see another New England-made object that compares to this jar in form, size and glaze-style. This jar may be a lone survivor today. It is possible that this jar could have been manufactured as-early-as 1780, which would place its production during the American Revolution.

Note: This jar also has a letter or a sympbol scratched into it - it appears like it could be a letter 'J.' This would have occurred after the jar had been fired in the potter's kiln. It is a strong possibility that a previous owner marked the jar. The mark may have been a symbol for what the jar held; although, it may also have represented the owner. I should also mention that this jar likely possessed a lid, which is now lost or broken. The jar is also covered in fingerprints from when the potter was throwing and glazing this object.

My 4-Year-Old Niece, Alexis Pictured with the Large Jar
Notice the Size of the Jar
Likely Late-18th Century New England-Made Red Earthenare Jar
Possibly Related to the Bugbee Pottery in South Woodstock, CT or Brimfield, MA
Reportedly Found in the Brimfield, MA-Area
Circa 1780-1799
Stands 13 3/4" Tall
Purchased Yesterday at an Antique Show in Portsmouth, NH
Acquired from Massachusetts Antiques Dealer, Samuel Herrup
Another View of the Jar
View of One Handle
View of the Other Handle
View of a Symbol or an Object Scratched into the Jar by a Previous Owner
View of the Interior
View of the Base
View of the Note
Reads 'Probably made in / Woodstock, CT by / Bugbee'

Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come...

Sunday, March 6, 2016

A Wonderful Red Earthenware Pitcher Acquired Today at a Nan Gurley Antique Show in Portsmouth, New Hampshire

I was fortunate to purchase a wonderful black-glazed red earthenware pitcher today at a Nan Gurley Antique Show in Portsmouth, New Hampshire. These pictures really do not serve this object justice for how it actually appears in-hand. This is a wonderfully-made pitcher.

The pitcher is attributed to coastal Massachusetts during the circa 1770-1820 period. There is a very-good possibility that it was made in the southeastern Massachusetts potter's industry located in the communities to the west of New Bedford, Massachusetts along the Taunton River. The underlying glaze found on part of belly's base is a characteristic of wares that were made in this region.

Although, written faintly in pencil, on the base, it reads, "160-73 / Attributed Durham CT / DURHAM." (Note: the writing does not photograph very-well.)

Durham is a former eighteenth and nineteenth-century farming village in Middlesex County, Connecticut located near the Connecticut River. It is also located to the northeast of New Haven, Connecticut, and just to the north of the Atlantic Ocean. The New Haven-area was a major region for stoneware production in the late-eighteenth and nineteenth-centuries; however, there is not a lot of red earthenware properly attributed to the New Haven-area today.

Unfortunately, there is no documented red earthenware potter known in Durham, Connecticut today. I have been unsuccessful in finding any evidence that supports any type of pottery production in Durham. Rather, my guess is that this product may have been originally discovered in Durham, but that does not mean it was made in Durham.

Eighteenth and early-nineteenth-century Massachusetts potters are known to have shipped their products elsewhere in New England. It's not surprising, either that Massachusetts-made products have been discovered in early contexts in Connecticut dating back decades. For example, Massachusetts author, Lura Woodside Watkins uncovered a variety of products made to the south of Boston in Connecticut in the 1930's and the 1940's - some of these objects are pictured in her important book, 'Early New England Potters and Their Wares.' These objects are owned by the Smithsonian in Washington, D.C. and Old Sturbridge Village in Sturbridge, Massachusetts today.

 18th or Early-19th Century Black-Glazed Red Earthenware Pitcher
Attributed to Southern Coastal Massachusetts
Purchased Today at a Nan Gurley Antique Show in Portsmouth, NH
Circa 1770-1820
Stands 12" Tall
 View of the Handle
 View of the Incised Decoration
 View of the Interior
View of the Base and the Underlying Glaze

Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come...

Saturday, March 5, 2016

A Rare 19th Century Slip-Decorated Red Earthenware Shaving Mug Owned by Old Sturbridge Village in Massachusetts

This morning I am going to show a few highlights from my visit to Old Sturbridge Village's storage facility in Sturbridge, Massachusetts yesterday with Boston archaeologist, Joe Bagley. I have decided that I am going to separate these objects between different articles since there is plenty to share.

I am always on the lookout for products made at the Charles A. Lawrence Pottery (circa 1866-1906) in Beverly, Massachusetts after 1865. I truly believe this is an important potter's business to understand today.

Charles A. Lawrence was a landmark potter in respect to his creative vision, and the utilitarian and decorative products that were manufactured under his guidance between circa 1866-1906. Fortunately, I have been able to discover new forms that can be attributed to his production since the research involved with this business is relatively new, and ongoing today.

Nonetheless, I was surprised when I saw this nineteenth-century slip-decorated red earthenware shaving mug yesterday at Old Sturbridge Village. This is a style of slip-decoration that Lawrence undoubtedly applied at his business; although, it is also a style of slip-decoration that became popular with North Carolina potters in the twentieth-century. According to Stephen C. Compton's book, 'North Carolina Pottery: Earthenware, Stoneware and Fancyware,' this decoration is called "swirl" or "swirl ware" when mentioning the North Carolina products. Interestingly, I find it fascinating that Lawrence was applying this type of decoration decades before it reportedly became popular with potters elsewhere in America.

When Lawrence produced this shaving mug form it was also a newer style that had been introduced to the American red earthenware industry. Generally, this form is rare today; however, it is also another example of how Charles A. Lawrence was at the forefront with his creative, and sometimes daring-style in Beverly, Massachusetts before 1900.

 Rare 19th Century Red Earthenware Shaving Mug
Attributed to the Charles A. Lawrence Pottery in Beverly, Mass.
Circa 1870
Stands Approximately 4" Tall
Photo Courtesy: Old Sturbridge Village - Sturbridge, Mass.
 Another View of the Shaving Mug
Photo Courtesy: Old Sturbridge Village - Sturbridge, Mass.
 View of the Interior
Photo Courtesy: Old Sturbridge Village - Sturbridge, Mass.
View of the Handle
Photo Courtesy: Old Sturbridge Village - Sturbridge, Mass.

This is a similar nineteenth-century slip-decorated red earthenware creamer or small pitcher that I discovered near Lake Winnipesaukee in Meredith, New Hampshire a little more-than a month ago. I found it for $9.00 in a small shop in the town's downtown-area. It matches a form, also attributed to the C.A. Lawrence Pottery, which is owned by the Smithsonian in Washington, D.C.

In my opinion: any type of slip-decorated red earthenware from the Lawrence Pottery is very-rare today.

Rare 19th Century Slip Decorated Red Earthenware Creamer 
Attributed to C.A. Lawrence Pottery - Beverly, MA
Circa 1870
Stands 4 7/8" Tall
Found Yesterday in a Shop in Meredith, NH
Paid $9

Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come...