Hyde Park Country Auctions, located near the Hudson River in Poughkeepsie, New York, has acquired, on consignment, a large selection of stoneware for the company's upcoming sale this weekend on Saturday January 9th. Much of the stoneware comes from a collection, which was kept in Dutchess County, New York. It seems there will be objects available for every budget - and, also objects that will be catered for beginning and advanced collectors. Personally, I don't know the history of the collection, but a quick study of the fresh-to-the-market items suggests this is a longtime or possibly even a lifelong collection.
Undoubtedly, the object that will garner the most attention in this sale is a very-rare one-gallon stoneware jug made at Luman Norton's Pottery in Bennington, Vermont during the circa 1823 to 1833 period. The jug is stamped, '
L. Norton & Co.'
According to the auctioneer, "
This rare and important one-gallon stoneware jug is decorated with a rare incised flower flanked by two incised birds. The jug is completely original (reportedly no restoration). The jug is in excellent condition with no chips, cracks or repairs."
The base of this jug also possesses what appears to be an inscribed signature - whether this is a potter's mark or another form of identification is a topic that I would need to further research. However, maybe someone reading this article will recognize this unusual mark.
The Bennington Museum in Bennington, Vermont owns an incredible selection of choice earthenware, red earthenware and stoneware objects that were produced in Bennington in the late-eighteenth and nineteenth-centuries - a focal point with this collection is the variety of birds that adorned various Bennington stoneware forms. This was also a subject of a book that was published in 1991, appropriately titled, '
The Birds of Bennington.'
The auctioneer is completely correct when they said that this was a rare object. Most of the bird decorations that were incorporated with the Bennington products were painted in cobalt decoration. Instead, this object demonstrates a pair of birds, which have been drawn or incised into the clay - and, then colored or highlighted with cobalt. This is an early style. This is also an early example of a bird that was used as decoration in the Bennington industry. Many of the birds that are known today were produced after 1830.
I've quickly reviewed a number of auction results from the past decade - and, I could only find one other object that is tied to the Bennington industry, which was incised with a bird. That object sold through Crocker Farm in Sparks, Maryland in 2007. The decoration showed a "
finely incised bird perched on a tree." The design was prominently placed on a double-handled water cooler that stood twenty-inches tall. It was also stamped twice by the maker, '
Julius Norton.' It was also incised with the name, '
S. Keyes.' The cooler was attributed to the circa 1840 period.
Understandably, it has been nearly a decade since that cooler sold when it achieved a price of more-than $36,000; although, stoneware prices for important American-made objects are what Crocker Farm has described as an "
all-time high today." None-the-less, with an estimate of $10,000 to $20,000 - it will be interesting to see how this fresh-to-the-market jug does this weekend. It should be no surprise, either to learn that this is a highly desired object once Saturday arrives and the auction begins.
19th Century One-Gallon Stoneware Jug Made at the L. Norton & Co. Pottery in Bennington, VT
The Incised Decoration is Extremely-Rare
Circa 1823-1833
Stands 11 3/4" Tall
Will Sell on Saturday January 9, 2015
Pre-Auction Estimate: $10,000-$20,000
Photo Courtesy: Hyde Park Country Auctions - Poughkeepsie, NY
View of the Inscribed Mark on the Base
Photo Courtesy: Hyde Park Country Auctions - Poughkeepsie, NY
Overall, this collection consists of stoneware products made in Vermont, Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania. A few objects, which also grabbed my attention, were a pair of products that were produced in New York City in the early-1800's. These objects would normally sell for thousands-of-dollars; however, each object is damaged. This could be a good opportunity, for a collector, who may not need a 'perfect' example for their collection. And, despite the damage, these are also rare objects to find in any type of condition today.
This first object is attributed to the Crolius family in Manhattan, New York during the circa 1810 period. The Crolius name is synonymous with America's earliest stoneware. According to the Green-Wood Historic Fund in Brooklyn, New York, "In 1730, William Crolius, a German immigrant from the Rhineland (Germany), which itself had a rich tradition of pottery making, established his stoneware business on Pot Baker's Hill in Manhattan. In all, there were fifteen Crolius potters, including six named William, five Johns, one George and three Clarksons. The family tradition may have begun in 1730, but it continued well into the 1800's."
What makes this object so special is the word 'PICKLES' that has been stamped on the ovoid jar. This is a rare mark to find today, and an equally rare form.
I believe this jar could have been made by Clarkson Crolius (1774-1843), who was the grandson of William Crolius; although, Clarkson was not only a potter, but he was also a New York City politician, who was elected to the Speaker of the New York Assembly in 1825. He also fought in the War of 1812. Ultimately, he was an important figure in New York City during the nineteenth-century, who is known for more than only stoneware today.
Early-19th Century Stoneware Jar Attributed to the Crolius Family in Manhattan, NY
The Jar is Stamped 'PICKLES'
Possibly Made by Clarkson Crolius (1774-1843)
Circa 1810
Stands 10" Tall
Will Sell on Saturday January 9, 2015
Photo Courtesy: Hyde Park Country Auctions - Poughkeepsie, NY
Closer Look at the 'PICKLES' Stamp
Photo Courtesy: Hyde Park Country Auctions - Poughkeepsie, NY
Honestly, this next object could be a wonderful opportunity for someone to purchase a terrific example of Manhattan-made stoneware cheaper since it is damaged. An example of this important potter's work is a 'must-have' for any serious scholar or collector of New York City stoneware today.
In some ways, I compare this individual's work to the enslaved potters employed in the Edgefield District in South Carolina in the mid-nineteenth-century.
Brandt Zipp, a specialist at Crocker Farm, who is also responsible for the company's website has done extensive research on the history of this potter. Brandt is actually responsible for identifying this individual as an African-American rather than a white potter, which makes this individual historically important in respect to the period that he was employed.
According to Brandt's website (commeraw.com), "Thomas W. Commeraw, the well-known New York stoneware potter of the late-eighteenth and early-nineteenth-centuries, was not--as previously thought--simply another potter of European descent working beside the venerated Crolius and Remmey families. Commeraw was a Manhattan stoneware potter who produced thousands of vessels -- many of which survive -- from around 1796 until 1819. He was, until the announcement of this project (Brandt's forthcoming book), believed to be a white potter of French descent. But he was not. He was an African-American."
The New York Times has also taken notice of Brandt's research, "Thomas W. Commeraw, an African-American ceramist in early-19th-century New York, ran a workshop on the Lower East Side waterfront. He painted blue scallops, tassels and petals on beige and tan containers for gallons of oysters, preserved fruit and alcohol, among other products.
No one quite knows how he learned his trade and built a business that produced perhaps thousands of pots a year.
Brandt Zipp has uncovered details about Commeraw's clients, including black church leaders and abolitionists, and tantalizing hints that the ceramist helped soldiers protect New York forts during the War of 1812."
This jug could be a good opportunity for a stoneware collector to own an example of Commeraw's signed (stamped) work that will sell for less than normal due to the damage; however, the decoration, which is the most important aspect of this jug remains in excellent condition.
Commeraw's most prolific stoneware is known to sell for thousands, if not, tens-of-thousand-of-dollars today. His work is represented in museum's and outstanding private collections across the country.
Early-19th Century Two-Gallon Stoneware Jug Made by Thomas Commeraw - Manhattan, NY
Circa 1805
Stands 14 1/2" Tall
Will Sell on Saturday January 9, 2015
Photo Courtesy: Hyde Park Country Auctions - Poughkeepsie, NY
A Closer Look at Commeraw's Mark on the Jug
Photo Courtesy: Hyde Park Country Auctions - Poughkeepsie, NY
View of the Damage
Photo Courtesy: Hyde Park Country Auctions - Poughkeepsie, NY
Next week, I will write a followup article that will identify how the Bennington jug does at the auction.
Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come...