Over the past few years, I have accumulated two pieces of green-glazed hand-thrown red earthenware from shops in Salem, Massachusetts and New Bedford, Massachusetts that I initially thought were produced at Thomas Nickerson's Merrimac Pottery Company (Circa 1897-1908) in Newburyport, Massachusetts; however, that idea soon faded the more I examined each object. The objects appeared early (i.e. 19th century) to me, but I just couldn't pinpoint where they were made. Never-the-less, they have both sat in the upstairs part of my house with the majority of my art pottery collection since they were first discovered.
I guess it's ironic that a few days ago, a woman, from Maine posted a red earthenware pitcher in a private redware research group on Facebook that she discovered in Caribou, Maine - she was seeking more information about the multi-colored pitcher that was stamped on the base, '
Frey'. The pitcher's form matched the object that I had discovered in New Bedford. Undoubtedly, it was the same potter. She had already conducted some research about this potter - and, she identified that the American Folk Art Museum in New York City shared an equal interest with this potter's work.
The museum published an article in the Fall 2004 edition of the museum's magazine, '
Folk Art: Magazine of the Folk Art Museum' that identified these products as having been made at the Frey Pottery in Washington Township in Pennsylvania before 1846; however, I do question what was made during this period and what may have been made afterwards in what I describe in the later part of this report. Undeniably, these are products made by what I would describe as an important nineteenth-century and early twentieth-century potter's business from rural Pennsylvania. From what I have briefly read and studied - it seems that there could be some comparison made between the Frey, Stahl and Medinger family names in Pennsylvania today. I will eventually explain why I make this connection in this report.
(Left) 19th Century Green Glazed Red Earthenware Vase Made at the Frey Pottery in PA
Stands 5 3/4" Tall
Recently Found in a Shop in Salem, Mass.
(Right) 19th Century Green Glazed Red Earthenware Pitcher Made at the Frey Pottery in PA
Stands 6 3/4" Tall
Recently Found in a Shop in New Bedford, Mass.
View of the Interiors
View of the Bases
The questions I will pose before this report moves forward - Why is this potter's business not better known today? Why is this family of potter's products not held in the same regards as potters who were employed elsewhere in America who operated behind a similar idea? Let me explain.
19th Century Red Earthenware Pitcher with a Multi-Colored Glaze
Made at the Frey Pottery in Washington, Township, PA
The Base is Stamped 'Frey'
Recently Discovered in Caribou, ME
Reportedly Circa 1810-1846
Stands 5 1/2" Tall
Photo Courtesy: Alyssa Levesque - Maine
View of the Handle
Photo Courtesy: Alyssa Levesque - Maine
View of the Interior
Photo Courtesy: Alyssa Levesque - Maine
View of the Base with the 'Frey' Mark
Photo Courtesy: Alyssa Levesque - Maine
Close Up of the 'Frey' Mark
Photo Courtesy: Alyssa Levesque - Maine
According to the American Folk Art Museum, "
Variegated and iridescent blues resulting from the firing of cobalt glaze on this beautiful wide mouthed jar create a rippling, water effect over its visible turnings. Occasional streaks of pure pigment in the glaze are possibly the result of hand-grinding, which leaves some irregularity in the size of the particles. Cobalt is usually applied as a calligraphic or representational element on American stoneware, and, because of its high expense, was typically used sparingly. Its appearance on a redware clay body is in itself rare; the sheer extravagance of the overall cobalt glaze on this jar is virtually unparalleled.
Little is known about the Frey pottery (today), whose mark is impressed on the (jar's) base. It was in operation by 1810, when Henry Frey moved onto his father-in-law's farm in a rural area of Washington Township, Pennsylvania (which was very close to where John Bell's pottery was located in the Shenandoah Valley in Waynesboro, Pennsylvania). After Frey died in 1821, the farm was divided among his four sons. The pottery continued to be run by (his sons) Henry Jr. and George, and during this period the area was renamed Freytown. After Henry Jr.'s death, George Frey maintained the pottery until (his death) 1846."
19th Century Red Earthenware Jar with Cobalt Glaze
Made at the Frey Pottery in Washington, Township, PA
The Base is Stamped 'Frey'
Pictured in the Fall 2004 American Folk Art Museum Magazine
Reportedly Circa 1810-1846
Stands 11" Tall
Photo Courtesy: American Folk Art Museum - New York City
After reading about the American Folk Art Museum's interest in this business' work - I decided to research the pottery produced at this company since some of it appears to have an art potter's type glaze - and, what I found is that this family must have kept producing red earthenware past 1846. Surprisingly, this business appears to have embraced the art potter's movement that happened during the Arts & Crafts Period. I was rather surprised with what my quick research revealed.
What I found online (past auction results) was an absolutely impressive rare group of hand-thrown vibrantly glazed red earthenware lamp bases that should be held in the same regard today as the lamp bases that were made at companies like the William Grueby Pottery in South Boston, Massachusetts and the Merrimac Pottery Company in Newburyport, Massachusetts in the early twentieth-century. Tiffany even contracted with some of these companies to produce lamp bases that eventually stood below early Tiffany lamp shades. The Frey Pottery products certainly appear rare today. Is it possible that not all of this output is understood today? Personally, I believe that if these were New England-made products from the Arts & Crafts Period that they would be highly sought after today - and, held in the highest regards.
It is my interpretation that the American Folk Art Museum is completely correct when they said that "not a lot is known about the Frey Pottery today"; however, the family must have kept producing pottery after 1846. My initial theory is that either - A) the pottery continued with production after George Frey died in 1846 by another family member, or B) the family saw an intermission with their production for years, if not, decades that resumed during the Arts & Crafts Era employing the same 'Frey' stamp that was reportedly used on products before 1846. It should be noted that John Bell operated a pottery in nearby Waynesboro, Pennsylvania where the majority of the Bell Pottery products were marked with a stamp. Could the Bell Pottery have influenced the Frey Pottery to incorporate their own stamp? The idea is only theory, but it is definitely worth a consideration. I should also mention that the Frey Pottery operated close to a number of important potters who were located in Haegerstown, Maryland and Thurmont, Maryland - but, they were also tied to the larger group of potters, who were employed throughout the Shenandoah Valley.
I'm actually very-surprised that some of these products have not received more attention today - I feel a significant art potter employed in a rural part of Pennsylvania producing hand-crafted (art) pottery with wonderful bright colored glazes is a 'BIG' deal today.
These lamps are especially a big deal (at least to me) because they date from the period when lamps first became fashionable in the American household from around the turn of the twentieth-century - and, the years (or, few decades) that followed. The use of the household table lamp first became popular in urban areas before their availability later spread to rural parts of America. The fact that a traditional red earthenware potter was throwing red earthenware lamp bases and glazing them with beautiful (expensive) colors in rural Pennsylvania seems significant (to me). I also assume that it's a sure fact that the later Frey pottery was also producing other forms aside just from red earthenware lamp bases. For this reason, I think it is difficult to say whether certain objects are from the 1810-1846 period - or, the later nineteenth and early-twentieth-century period since the stamp is said to be the same impressed mark employed during both periods. This is certainly an instance that would truly benefit from archaeology to accurately identify what was made at the Frey Pottey between 1810-1846.
The reason I am willing to compare the Frey, Stahl and Medinger family names today is a result of these names successfully operating red earthenware businesses in the twentieth-century that grew from companies that were originally established in the nineteenth-century. Few Pennsylvania family businesses were able to accomplish this feat - and, all three names are also associated with the German community in Pennsylvania.
Late 19th or Early 20th Century Red Earthenware Lamp Base with a Vibrant Colored Glaze
The Base is Stamped 'Frey'
Circa 1890's-1920's
Stands 13" Tall
Photo Courtesy: Embassy Auctions International - Kinzers, PA
Another View of the Lamp Base
Photo Courtesy: Embassy Auctions International - Kinzers, PA
View of the Base Stamped 'Frey'
Photo Courtesy: Embassy Auctions International - Kinzers, PA
Late 19th or Early 20th Century Red Earthenware Lamp Base with a Vibrant Colored Glaze
Recently Found in a Farmhouse in Audubon, PA
The Base is Stamped 'Frey'
Circa 1890's-1920's
Lamp Base Stands 8" Tall
Photo Courtesy: WorthPoint
However, this pottery doesn't appear to be completely unknown today - this pitcher was pictured on the website, 'Antiques & Auctions News' - where Pennsylvania collector and dealer, Brad Hamilton brought it with him to the 2013 Leesport Holiday Antique Show in Berks County, Pennsylvania. He asked $1,000 for the beautiful multi-colored object. It was marked 'Frey' on the base.
19th Century Red Earthenware Jar with Multi-Colored Glaze
Made at the Frey Pottery in Washington, Township, PA
The Base is Stamped 'Frey'
Reportedly Circa 1810-1846
Photo Courtesy: Antique & Auctions News and Brad Hamilton
Here is another beautiful polychrome decorated pitcher that was sold in a group lot at a Discovery Americana Sale at Skinner Auctions in Marlborough, Massachusetts in 2013. Overall. the lot brought $1,400 before the auction premiums were added; however, my guess is that overall interest was devoted to other objects in this lot rather than the relatively unknown pitcher that sold in New England.
19th Century Red Earthenware Jar with Multi-Colored Glaze
Made at the Frey Pottery in Washington, Township, PA
Reportedly Circa 1810-1846
Photo Courtesy: Skinner, Inc. - Boston & Marlborough, MA
I really feel that this is a family potter's name that needs more attention today - these were skillfully made objects that were adorned in some of the most beautiful glazes that I have ever seen from a red earthenware potter before - no matter if it was an art potter or a more traditional utilitarian red earthenware potter. I'll certainly be on the look out for Frey Pottery objects in my future travels.
Please Stay Tuned...Much More to Come...